Saturday, May 31, 2008

Would you die for love????

If the kind of movies watched had any effect on what people turn out to be and believe in, Indians would be the ideal people. Honest, good humoured and very tolerant. Because the average Bollywood movie plot is girl meets guy ,they fall in love, a villain opposes but he fails and they live happily ever after. Never does evil win and murder go unpunished except when they are the viilain's goons.

But sadly that is not true. India is a harsh harsh place divided along casteist and religious lines . While we may like on screen social barrier breaking love stories no one wants to tolerate one in their background.

As an idealist, I believe in the supremacy of love. I believe in the romanticism of the idea of love as the purest emotion.


Maybe I am living in the wrong place. In fact maybe I should migrate to some idyllic liberal country where no one gives a damm what anyone else is doing!

Because to break barriers in India can be dangerous. Because this is India. A place where village panchayats sentence young lovers to death. Where parents murder their daughters and even sons in the name of family honour. Where women are seen as inherently weak who need to be protected and guarded by fathers, brothers and other male relatives. Where marrying outside the caste or community gaurantees social boycott.

And the toll only climbs higher every year. And mostly these murders go unreported , justice is never served and a travesty is called a suicide or a mystery death.

While the metros have become swanky , cosmopolitan places India for most of its part remains heart - brutal. Like an illiterate clothed in a three piece suit, appearance does not matter, the devil is always just below the surface.

Every time I hear about a love for murder I feel anguished. It is the ultimate price to pay for love, the ultimate sacrifice. And I see it daily. My morning dose of newspaper is like a dose of bitter milk. After having read it all, I wish I had not read it just to avoid the senseless pain and disillusionment.

Recently the case of the murder of Nitish Katara got over and thankfully justice was served.

Nitish Katara was a 24 year old business executive in Delhi who was murdered in the early hours of February 17, 2002, by the son of an influential Indian politician. The son of an IAS officer in the Ministry of Shipping, Nitish had recently graduated from the Institute of Management Technology, Ghaziabad. There, he had fallen in love with his classmate, Bharti Yadav, who comes from a criminal-politician family.A trial court on Wednesday found Vikas Yadav and his cousin Vishal Yadav guilty of killing Nitish.

In their own words in a recorded confession which was leaked to the media but could not be used as evidence due to a legality.
"The affair was damaging my family's reputation. I never approved of their relationship. ... Using all my strength, I hit Nitish's head with a hammer. He fainted and after a while he died. We drove one kilometre and then we threw his body onto the road.
Then we took the diesel from our car's tank, poured it on Nitish's body and we set it on fire. Then we drove to Delhi."

Such a tragic waste of life. Tragically the girl retracted her initial statement during the trial and denied being ever involved with Nitish. He died for her but in his death the idea for which he died itself became questionable.

The Yadav family never liked Bharti's liaison, and Nitish had received threats several times. However, he was an idealist, and believed in "standing up to injustice"

But lets not demonise a girl who lost the love of her life. She must have been under immense pressure. It was family after all. Still I wish instead of a life sentence, the brothers had been given the noose. And maybe as a revenge for the act inflicted on her by her family she should have snapped all ties and instead herself asked for the noose for her guilty family.

But why is it that India still cannot accept love marriages. Because love has to be celebrated. We celebrate the love of a mother for a child,love between two siblings, love between friends and so many other places. So what is so wrong about love between a guy and a girl when its not 'arranged'. Cannot society accept them.

"Agar dil mein ho zor to duniya se dushmani kar lo,
Warna jahaan maa-baap kahen wahin shaadi kar lo"

And the above line is true. To marry for love breaking across the hypocritical social lines can be fatal. Nitish Katara could have been any of us. Bright and well educated, his relationship with Bharti was nothing out of ordinary.

No one deserves to die like he did-"hit by a hammer and burnt by the roadside."

In India there is an emphasis on arranged marriages. They worked for our parents and even at 22 or however old I may be it seems I am incompetent to choose a partner. I say this. Love is finally the pursuit of happiness. As parents if the child decides to pursue happiness himself it should not be an issue. They should be happy. But parents seldom are, forever warning boys of morally loose girls and girls of being fooled by guys. Also only an idiot would deny inter-caste marriages face a lot of pressure and lets not talk about inter-religious marriages where I think all couples should be given a gold medal for bravery. They after all crossed the final lines.

So I ask my musing "Was it worth it?" Is love worth the ultimate sacrifice? Or can we simply move on throwing love in the closest dust bin when the going gets hard.

And maybe the question we all have to ask ourselves. How far can we go for love.

6 comments:

heenad said...

i think india is changing and love marriages are being accepted at least in the bigger cities. and more so now then they were. yes its not widely acceptable throughout india. but small change is better no change. its pretty normal to get to know someone before ending up married to them. love is just an illusion. most of the greatest love stories are only so coz they end in tragedy. they never end up passing the rituals of mundane life and small fights/ego issues. love i believe is fleeting. sometimes you feel it and sometimes you just dont. love is also changeable, sometimes it turns into pure hate, other times friendship and sometimes its not even love just you think it is, thats when its easy to throw it in the closest dust bin.

ure right about parents seldom being happy. and sometimes its not cause they dont love you, its simply coz they are losing that hold on you. when you start becoming indepedant and making your own decisions, its never easy on parents.

Ashraf's Pen said...

Actually I typed out a long reply but my comp suffered a blue screen of death. And now I simply dont have the guts to type such a long reply again.

Though I shall try.

I agree the world is changing and love marriages are getting accepted. However there are times when parents are too rigid to accept the match(few accept inter-caste much less inter-religous).

Most couples go ahead and marry anyway while others buckle and it end.

Most who go ahead face some hostility around them but it depends. NOt much for inter-caste ones. Anyway there is a backlash in some of the remaining cases from family or society(mostly panchayats in villages).

Ashraf's Pen said...

Moving on this is what is so tragic. No one deserves to die for love.

But in India this happens just too often for comfort. People dont even raise an eyelid. Its so common.

Love is definitely not an illusion. What u refer to is more of lust, crush or simply infatuation.

True love is that feeling where u want to enjoy the other person's company. His\her happiness is supreme. Everything else is secondary.

The soft spot never disappears. Even after 10 years seeing the one u love will make u go weak in the kness.

Ashraf's Pen said...

So I disagree that true love metmorphoses or we can throw it in the dustbin.

But then I am the eternal romantic.

If I were to stop believing in love I would most probably be unable to pen poetry or explore the ideas of love in my writing. In a way , I have to believe to survive the day.

:X

To each his own(and her when gender demands so).


Anyway parents esp in the subcontinent context are seldom happy when their children find a fiance coz they think to arrange the kids marriage is a duty of theirs and in a way we deny them the chance to fulfill their duties.

But it is understandable. To the parent the child is always a child n they think the child even when he/she is quite grown up is still immature to make such decisions.

However they should ideally accept the kids decision after warning them of how big a decision they have made.

After all kids do grow up.

heenad said...

lol. sorry to burst your bubble ashraf. ghalib nei farmaya hai ishq hai khalal hai dimaag ka.
you will see. =). im an optimist too and romatic too, but Im not wearing rose coloured glasses anymore.

Ashraf's Pen said...

lolz.

I definitely am not living in a fantasy world. I am a hosteller and cant possible be that naive.

I beleive in stuff which need not necessarily have a reality. I acknowledge te fact. Its like an abstract function. To create an object of it would be plain foolishness.

Faraz said "Agar dil mein ho himmat to duniya se bagawat kar lo,
Warna jahaan maa baap kahen waheen shaadi kar lo"

Love that is not returned lasts forever. I acknowledge the reality in the world.
I do accept many times relationships do not work out. In fact I say the figure is 99.9%. But the .1% is enough. My point specifically related to honour killings and societal pressure in the Indian context. And the toll is definitely high